Who is better able to perform minor operations say an appendix..A physican's assistant or a nurse pratictioner

Say I am on a desert island and one of each were on the island. And only one had to make the final cuts and make the final say on where to cut. Which of the 2 would you rather do it. Say they both have 5 years as a PA and NP. Who is better and why? Which of the 2 would you rather make the final decision on which antibiotic to give to your child? One last one.which one would you rather deliver your baby?
Answers:
np of coarse.
they are almost dr. and a pa is a nice name for a nurse

---

PA Want to bet

---

In the case you can only chose one to make the decisions I would choose the physican's assistant in this case because she has plenty of practicing in watching the doctor doing. That is what they are there for to learn.
But to give my child medicine I would want the Nurse Practictioner.
And to deliver my baby.Nurse Practictioner.most have general experience there.

---

I'd want a general surgeon.

---